Re: somatic delusions of infection or disease are not rare in psychiatrically ill patients.On May 16, 10:41 am, chronichel...@yahoo,com wrote:
> On May 16, 6:59 am, BrentB <borgersbr...@yahoo,com > wrote:
>
>
>
> > On May 15, 2:48 pm, chronichel...@yahoo,com wrote:
>
> > > On May 15, 12:32 pm, BrentB <borgersbr...@yahoo,com > wrote:
>
> > > > On May 15, 1:55 pm, chronichel...@yahoo,com wrote:
>
> > > > > On May 15, 11:38 am, BrentB <borgersbr...@yahoo,com > wrote:
>
> > > > > > The second point is that seemingly innocuous "folk remedies," such as
> > > > > > the one in our case, can lead to permanent harm. Given the fact that
> > > > > > somatic delusions of infection or disease are not rare in
> > > > > > psychiatrically ill patients, the use of colloidal silver might appear
> > > > > > attractive to vulnerable patients. Clinicians are urged to be aware of
> > > > > > the popularity and potential harm of the "remedy" presented in this
> > > > > > case.
>
> > > > > > http :// ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/full/165/5/649-a
>
> > > > > But from the article I don't see the connection of psychiatrically ill
> > > > > and coloidal silver. Did the person had a history of mental illness?
> > > > > was he on any medication?.
> > > > >People that are ignorant or naive can be
> > > > > victims of scams but that doesn't necessarily imply that they have to
> > > > > be psychiatrically ill. Sure the guy could've not have any chronic
> > > > > infection but how did the Drs. established that his symptoms were
> > > > > psychosomatic? it could've been a condition hard to diagnose, such as
> > > > > M.E., M.S, Alzheimer (which causes dementia), CJD etc. Some of these
> > > > > conditions take years before they can show evidence on MRIs, spinal
> > > > > tap, etc. In fact M.S was in the past considered psychosomatic and
> > > > > referred to as hysterical paralysis.
>
> > > > Good stuff and I'd agree...I wasn't that interested in the colloidal
> > > > silver aspect. The fact that "somatic delusions of infection" are not
> > > > rare is what I found very interesting. A better description would be
> > > > chronically infected people who know damn well what's going on.
>
> > > But how do you establish a somatic delusion of infection with somebody
> > > that knows damn well what's going on?
> > > and let's assume that it could
> > > be easily established, then how do they differentiated a condition
> > > with a different etiology (genetic, auto-immune) from a somatic
> > > delusion of his symptoms? the information given in that article is not
> > > enough (at least in my eyes) to establish that his perceived symptoms
> > > were somatic in nature (even though is written as if it was a matter
> > > of fact, or that the person even suffered from any psychiatri
> > > illness).
>
> > People who tell lies tend to state opinion as matters of fact. It's
> > annoying. Correct on your analysis...the dx of somatic delusion is
> > pulled from their butts. They even have the nerve to throw Morgellons
> > victims into the same dx despite obvious and easily found evidence of
> > a parasitic infection.
>
> But somatic delusion does exist, psychosomatic symptoms are real, it
> just that from the article I don't feel there is enough information to
> conclude that. It would've been interesting if the authors had
> included more information to reach their diagnosis, maybe they are
> right (or probably they are) but the feeling I got after reading that
> article was a generalization of a quick psychological assessment to
> explain the symptoms. A more responsible article would have included
> the history of the patient, ie: was he productive before he became
> "mentally" or physically ill?, was a history in his family of mental
> illness, what was his background (education etc), what were his
> symptoms, what kind of disease he thought he had acquired, what was
> his reason for attempting suicide? was that his first attempt? etc.
> There is a lot of information that is left out. An alternate
> explanation could be that the guy didn't had formal education, that he
> thought he could have acquired HIV and was relating his physical
> symptoms to that (symptoms that could've been manifested due to M.E
> for example), he thought (due to his lack of education or even
> intelligence) that colloidal silver could be the answer to his
> problems. After realizing that not only his symptoms didn't go away
> but also that he had developed argyria he went on to a crisis and
> attempted suicide. But again the article doesn't tell the whole story
> which I think is very misleading.
>
> About Morgellons I haven't read any evidence that would convince me is
> a parasitic infection (or any sort of infection), but I still keep an
> open mind about it.
What I would really like to see, is a case study where the person had
a delusion where he/she thought that his symptoms where somatic but
that in reality he was suffering from a physical condition. It should
work both ways right?