Re: Choc bar drugs pair will appeal
Sharky wrote:
> name wrote:
> > Sharky wrote:
> >> [..]
> >> Ignorant - I have a close family member who has diagnosed Bipolar CAUSED
> >> by too much cannabis in her youth! I have spent many an hour in the
> >> local mental health unit where she has been sectioned 3 times in four
> >> years due to relapses caused by starting to smoke it again.
> >> I've spent many hours talking to the doctors and staff of the unit who
> >> have no doubt that cannabis is the cause of Bipolar and other mental
> >> health problems, and met many of the other inmates who have the same
> >> problems.
> >>
> >> I spend half my time helping her stay off the weed - do you think I (or
> >> her carers) want some arseholes selling her cannabis chocolate (its
> >> safe, Cloughie says it is!).
> >> [..]
> >>
> >
> > This sounds like bullshit.. helping her stay off the weed?! Is she
> > unable to make decisions
> > regarding her own life?
>
> Err, being sectioned means that you have lost control of the decisions
> in your life, you have been locked up indefinitely - until you are
> 'stabilised' and they let you out!
> Doesn't that count?
I just don't see why cannabis has (or more specifically, people selling
cannabis have) to take the blame.
She might have gone through the same ordeal where alcohol abuse would
cause (or seem to cause) her
being sectioned or suffering from (or aggravating her) bi-polar
disorder. If it had been alcohol, you wouldn't
be able to change much about the situation that alcohol is freely
available to adults and consequently her
having access to alcohol. Blaming people who sell drugs (regardless of
whether it's alcohol or cannabis)
to 'vulnerable' people who are probably better off not taking those
drugs seems somewhat on par with people selling
peanuts to people with a nut-allergy. It might be a relatively rare
individual negative response that is no basis
for denying other responsible adults access to such substances or
blaming the people who provide these substances.
> Having been in hospital for 3 x 3 month (compulsory) stays in four
> years, she is unemployable, little social life outside the family and
> yes turns to weed to releive boredom if not kept busy by the family.
> Sorry if you don't beleive the 'bullshit' , but your family will have
> the fun of dealing with if you are unlucky to follow suit!
Although I sympathize with your situation, I don't think it's fair to
assert that cannabis is
the cause of the problem, although I do believe it's quite obvious
cannabis (like alcohol and other drugs) is
potentially detrimental for people who suffer from mental health
problems.
But you don't know whether or not the same situation could just as
easily have been triggered by other things,
like traumatic experiences and was sort of destined to surface one way
or the other anyhow.
> >
> > Also, where is the evidence (apart from your anecdotal account) that
> > weed causes bi-polar disorders?
> > I'm not necessarily saying weed is safe for people suffering from a
> > bi-polar condition or other mental health problems, but it might well
> > be that smoking weed in small quantities has a beneficial effect while
> > overdoing it potentially has detrimental effects like it seems to be
> > the case for schizophrenia.
> >
> Schizophrenia is just a few degrees round the dial from Bipolar, they
> are frequently confused - in fact the treatment for the two is similar
> until a diagnosis is made and often the diagnosis is wrong.
I was not suggesting that a bi-polar disorder is a form of
schizophrenia, just trying to
draw an analogy between cannabis as a risk factor in the development
and progression
of those two mental disorders.
>
> Anecdotal evidence does indeed say small amounts MAY be helpful, but
> consider the Bipolar mindset - when Manic they can do no wrong and want
> to smoke it all day, when in the low phase they couldn't give a fuck and
> will smoke it all day.
But by the same token they might drink excessively and I think that
wouldn't just pose a hazard to
their mental health, but it would completely wreck their liver and
brain as well.
>
> http :// www .rcpsych.ac.uk/mentalhealthinformation/mentalhealthproblems/alcoholanddrugs/cannabisandmentalhealth.aspx
>
> "Depression
>
> A study following 1600 Australian school-children, aged 14 to 15 for
> seven years, found that while children who use cannabis regularly have a
> significantly higher risk of depression, the opposite was not the case -
> children who already suffered from depression were not more likely than
> anyone else to use cannabis. However, adolescents who used cannabis
> daily were five times more likely to develop depression and anxiety in
> later life."
>
> and
>
> "Is there such a thing as 'cannabis psychosis'?
>
> Recent research in Denmark suggests that yes, there is. It is a
> short-lived psychotic disorder that seems to be brought on by cannabis
> use but which subsides fairly quickly once the individual has stopped
> using it. It's quite unusual though - in the whole of Denmark they found
> only around 100 new cases per year.
>
> However, they also found that:
>
> * Three quarters had a different psychotic disorder diagnosed
> within the next year
> * Nearly half still had a psychotic disorder 3 years later."
>
>
>
> I used to smoke cannabis, but wouldn't touch it again after what I've
> seen her go through.
> You want to dance with the devil, carry on, and good luck!
You have to realize that THC (one of the active ingredients in
cannabis) is a psychedelic substance
to some degree, which means it can (especially in high doses) induce
delusions or even hallucinations.
So it's a kind of subtle issue, but in my opinion the essential
question is whether or not (excessive) use
by people who are otherwise healthy and properly informed about
cannabis can result in schizophrenia
as a mental disorder.
Despite various claims by many qualified experts on psychiatric
conditions, it seems there is no
solid evidence yet to back up this assumption that cannabis causes
schizophrenia, although it has been
established cannabis poses a risk factor in it's development,
especially in case of people who are genetically
predisposed to develop this condition:
http :// news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/4104702.stm
"And just finally I would say that if there was a very strong
association between smoking cannabis as a youngster and developing
schizophrenia in later life, and I mean schizophrenia rather than
psychotic symptoms or psychosis, then you would expect that if you were
to monitor very carefully the rate of cannabis smoking in a particular
country where you could show that it was going up very markedly, then
you would expect to see the prevalence of schizophrenia going up
markedly too.
That hasn't been seen where it's been carefully looked for, for
example, in Australia. So I think one has to say that this is an
association which requires very careful future examination. But at the
moment a causal link between cannabis smoking and schizophrenia has not
been established."