Re: Sweet EmotionRichL wrote:
> Brian Running <brunning@XXameritechXX,net > wrote:
>>> Hey, I use either a pick or fingers for any given song, depending on
>>> (a) the sound I'm trying to create and (b) the intrinsic difficulties
>>> associated with each technique when applied to the song.
>>>
>>> In this case (being a guitarist by nature), I give (b) more weight
>>> over (a). There's nothing intrinsic in the sound of the bass in
>>> this song that leads me to believe that using a pick *intrinsically*
>>> degrades the part.
>> I agree with all of that, and I use a pick when the song requires it.
>> But there is no doubt, not by a long shot, that playing with fingers
>> is easier and much, much faster.
>
> For *you*, maybe.
> Try playing Dick Dale's "Miserlou" on, say, a steel-string or classical
> guitar using fingertips. Then we can get real about this. p.s...I'm a
> pretty decent fingerstyle player on guitar, but I recognize that there
> are times when it's not the right tool.
>
>> If it isn't for you, then you just need to practice your fingerstyle
> more.
>
> No question, I need to do that. But I'd argue that my skill with a
> pick, developed over 44+ years of guitar playing, gives me an advantage
> over many bassists when it comes to using a pick with bass. So maybe
> you need to practice your bass picking more? ;-)
>
>> You're a recovering guitarist, Rich, I'm glad to see that -- but
>> you're not fully recovered, yet. :-)
>
> I hesitate to use the phrase "recovering", since I'm still primarily a
> guitarist. But even there, technique "nazis" would be aghast at some of
> the techniques I use at times, like using my bare fingertips on a highly
> cranked up, overdriven guitar part when I want a more subdued attack
> (not to mention wrapping my thumb around the neck and using it on the
> 6th and sometimes 5th strings). I tend to use whatever works best for
> me at any given time (whether on guitar or bass). And yes, I'm still
> learning new things every day on both instruments and adjusting my
> preferences as I go. It wouldn't be any fun otherwise!
>
>
I'm a guitar player switched to bass now play both. I thought about a
pick. I even tried a pick. On this passage I just found the pick way
more awkward.