Re: FishOn Sat, 20 Oct 2007 13:22:49 -0700, Sgt. Giggles of the Kamikaze Gasbag
Squadron wrote:
> Eating Fish
>
> I received this letter from a notmilk reader this
> week:
>
> "Dear Notmilkman,
>
> I am a vegetarian who occasionally eats seafood. Is
> there really anything wrong with eating wild fish?"
>
> Yesterday (October 2, 2007), Utah's Salt Lake Tribune
> reported:
>
> "State issues new fish advisory for Utah Lake
> By Tom Wharton"
>
> It seems that Utah's Department of Health identified 209
> different PCBs (chlorinated man-made toxins) which are
> found in fish flesh.
>
> Utah's official advisory warns:
>
> "Consumption of carp and channel catfish be limited to
> one 4-ounce meal per month for adults and that children,
> pregnant women and women who can become pregnant avoid
> eating those fish from Utah Lake."
>
> Food for Thought regarding fish consumption by two
> of my favorite vegetarian Seventy-day Adventists.
> Please try to digest the following:
>
> "In many places fish become so contaminated by the
> filth on which they feed as to be a cause of disease.
> This is especially the case where the fish come in
> contact with the sewage of large cities. The fish
> that are fed on the contents of the drains may pass
> into distant waters and may be caught where the water
> is pure and fresh. Thus when used as food they bring
> disease and death on those who do not suspect the
> danger.
> - Ellen G. White, Ministry of Healing
It's foolish to assume there is any such thing as "pure" water in any
stream/lake in the U.S. Common harmful organisms are giardia and coccidia.
In high acid rain areas, water may be "crystal clear" because it's too
acidic for anything much to live in it.
After the Corps of Engineers built two flood control dams in my rural
northeast county, one (of three) impoundment turned out to be too acidic
to support fish life. When the state finally got around to testing fish in
the other two impoundments, predator species were found to be contaminated
with mercury; consumption was restricted to one fish meal a month for
children and pregnant women. The probable source of the mercury is
blow-in (along with the pollutants that cause the acid rain) from coal
burning plants to the West. PCBs are also primarily an industrial
pollutant.
---------
National Listing of Fish Advisories
Technical Fact Sheet: 2005/06 National Listing
http :// www .epa.gov/waterscience/fish/advisories/2006/tech.html
In 2005 and 2006, 22 states and the District of Columbia reported that
100% of their lake acres and river miles were under advisory for one or
more contaminants: Connecticut, District of Columbia, Florida, Illinois,
Indiana, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Missouri, Montana, New
Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma,
Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, West Virginia, and
Wisconsin.
---------
> "In Michigan and several other areas, Diphyllobothrium latum, the
fish
> tapeworn, has been identified in man. Opportunity for infection occurs
> when undercooked fish is eaten. A 51-year-old man passed a long, whitish
> string which he took to his physician. He had had no bowel complaints,
> but reported a fishing trip to the Northwest area eleven months before.
>
> The fish tapeworm normally lives in the small intestine of fish in
> subarctic and temperate regions. It is the largest tapeworm found in
> man. It competes with the host for nutrients, which is the major cause
> for disability produced in man. Especially notable is megaloblastic
> anemia due to vitamin B-12 deficiency since the tapeworm inhabits the
> parts of the small bowel where B-12 is absorbed. Numbness of the
> extremities is the most common complaint, along with fatigue, weakness,
> and dizziness. All of these are vague and non-specific complaints and
> can go on for years before the appropriate diagnosis is suspected." -
> Agatha Thrash, M.D.
>
> Got sushi?