Re: Photoshop CS3 Beta Indepth - BridgeW wrote:
> I have CS2 (PC platform). I stopped using the RAW converter (20D) after
>
> I realized there were two significant (and probably related) issues:
>
> 1. Tends to noisy shadows
> 2. Tends to clip the low end of the histogram on one or more channels
> (And yes I set the 'shadows' to zero and tried numerous other tweaks.)
>
>
> These complaints are in comparison to Canon Digital Photo Professional.
>
> I use DPP exclusively now because of these two issues (although I love
> the chromatic abberation correction in ACR).
> Any early comparison on the CS3 RAW converter regarding these two
> issues?
Not from me! <s.> So far, I've not had the time or inclination to do
good side-by-side comparisons of RAW converters, but there are others
here who've done great comparisons and written them up.
I've been using Lightroom for a while, and so the differences in CSIII
that might be apparent compared to CSII are even less so for me. My type
of photography currently doesn't lend itself to such analyses---- that's
my story and I am sticking to it!
If I see a good review, I'll try to remember to link it here.
--
John McWilliams